Fair Lawn High summons Jewish student for ‘Anti-Israel’ tweets

Fair Lawn High summons Jewish student for ‘Anti-Israel’ tweets

Did a social media exchange about Israeli policy run afoul of state anti-bullying law?

Bethany Koval (Twitter)
Bethany Koval (Twitter)

A Jewish New Jersey high school student of Israeli background is facing possible bullying charges stemming from Twitter posts that school administrators called anti-Israel.

An assistant principal at Fair Lawn High told Bethany Koval, 16, on Wednesday that she could be formally charged under New Jersey’s Anti-Bullying Bill of Rights Act, which could lead to suspension or expulsion from school, the Gothamist reported. The matter has been referred to the superintendent of schools.

In tweets about the 2014 Gaza war and the Israeli-Palestinian situation, Koval called Israel a “terrorist force” and said “Hamas is not extreme.” Another post on the social media site expressed happiness that a pro-Israel classmate had unfollowed her. Koval did not identify the student, but told a friend she would provide the name in a private message.

In a tweet, Koval said she does not believe that to be bullying.

“Her name was never mentioned. I never degraded her. They use ‘bullying’ as a guise to cover their pro-Israel, pro-censorship agenda,” she wrote.

Koval surreptitiously recorded parts of a meeting she had with a school administrator over the bullying accusations in which she called her tweets about Israel “controversial,” but not “problematic.”

“Well, that’s your interpretation,” the administrator responded. “There’s a state law that might interpret it differently.”

The teen has received a great deal of support on Twitter, where she has nearly 6,000 followers, many of whom now using the hashtag #IStandWithBenny. The international hacking group Anonymous also has backed Koval.

According to the New York Times, James Marcella, the principal of Fair Lawn High School, said in an email on Thursday that the issue had been referred to the superintendent of the Fair Lawn school district, Bruce Watson. Mr. Watson told the Times at the district
could not discuss confidential matters involving students but was obligated by New Jersey’s strict bullying law to investigate a complaint alleging harassment.

“At no time have District officials sought to censor or reprimand any
pupils for their online speech,” Mr. Watson wrote to the Times. “The investigation is focused solely on the factors we are required to apply by law and not upon any political opinions expressed by any pupils.”

read more: