Courage
Courage is a rare commodity. It can often be mistaken for outspokenness. More often, the term is applied to oppositional or iconoclastic positions. Perhaps most understandably, courage is often a comparative standard. Soldiers fighting and dying in war are considered as having displayed the most supreme form of personal courage.
Religiously, a most notable archetype of “halachic man” man was delineated as “heroic man” by Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik (reverentially referred to as “the Rav”). The ever-present awareness of an ethical sensitivity to the world we inhabit and the constancy of sanctifying life through religious awareness and observance is, for the Rav, the hallmark of religious courage.
It is illuminating to recognize that the foundational premise of courage may not be axiomatically ascertainable by the action taken. Fighting in a war may engage with courage, but it may also be a surrender of judgment, or the submission to military commands to conform with tasks accepted by others.
Get The Jewish Standard Newsletter by email and never miss our top stories Free Sign Up
How then should courage be defined? It is identifiable by a single thread that permeates personal thought and action. The tensile fiber that envelops human character with courage is personal autonomy. Absent the independence of the decision maker, courage is absent from the decision made.
Independence of thought, and the bravery to act upon that independence, does not necessarily render the action praiseworthy. It may be a courageous act notwithstanding any value judgment that may be placed on the action. To be clear, independent action may be part of a general consensus or it may stand apart. That which makes an action courageous is its lack of dependence on social acceptance or reliance on communal concurrence.
Personal sovereignty as the structural bond that defines courage allows for some challenging conclusions. An individual who was a Catholic bishop and converts to Judaism may be hailed as courageous but the same characterization may then be attributed to a rabbi who converts to Christianity. Courage does not necessarily define the decision made. Courage defines the self determination of the decision maker. The soldier who of his own volition risks his life for his country may be considered heroic without regard to the country or cause for which he independently chose to risk his life. The merit of the cause is distinct from the action which, if taken independently, may be classified as courageous. Actions we admire may remain admirable but lack courage, and actions that we oppose may remain objectionable yet be courageous. (It is noted that certain causes may be inhumane and, as such, attributing any positive character trait to the action, including courage, is morally unfathomable.)
There are a number of extraordinary rabbinic figures in Jewish history where the lessons of personal courage seem to have been lost. Today’s rabbinic authorities recount with reverence the heroism of certain rabbis of the past. Rabbi Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer is accurately credited with being the first in the religious world (and preceding Moses Hess and Theodore Herzl in the secular Jewish world) who in the 19th century advocated for religious Zionism and the creation of a Jewish state of Israel. The Baal Shem Tov, the founder of chasidism, is embraced for his exuberant independence in infusing Judaism with a vibrancy and spontaneity that invigorate Jewish practices and worship. Rabbi Sabato Morrais was courageous in opposing slavery in the United States and is greatly admired for that bravery today.
It is therefore more than noteworthy that Rabbi Kalischer was repudiated, disrespected, and rejected by most of the religious world in his time. His Zionist views were characterized as heresy by most of the Orthodox rabbinate and his views were considered by most rabbinic authorities as religiously dangerous. It is more than a historical footnote that the leading rabbinic figure at the time of the Baal Shem Tov was the Vilna Gaon. After the death of the Baal Shem Tov, the Vilna Gaon excoriated chasidism, ostracized his followers, and excommunicated the followers of chasidism through the attempted imposition of a cherem. It is a painful fact that no Orthodox rabbi joined Rabbi Morais in his attack on slavery. Sadly, other Orthodox rabbis at the time, including Rabbi Morris Raphael and Rabbi Isaac Leeser, provided halachic justification for the institution of slavery in reliance on supporting text from the Torah.
The near total absence of courage in the religious community at those momentous times — in support of the imaginative spirituality of chasidism, responding to the plea for religious Zionism, or proclaiming opposition to the loathsomeness of slavery — should shock our collective conscience. It is therefore a bewildering reality that in today’s world — when freedoms are threatened daily, when the urgent need for a social conscience is most pronounced, when the depraved character of many leaders pleads for rabbinic guidance — these courageous characters of our religious heritage are quoted but not imitated. These rabbis of the past are cherished as models but not emulated. The courageousness of these leaders is a source of religious pride but has not served as a prompt to courageous action.
The words and the deeds of these great rabbinic figures (and others like them) are inspirational paradigms of halachic courage. They were fearless in their leadership, heroic in the expression of their intuitive spirituality, and intrepid in their outspoken defense of morality and freedom.
In the 19th century, Rabbi Yisrael Salanter founded the Mussar movement. He stressed personal courage and independence in his ethical teachings. He recognized the vital linkage between the enchantment with social acceptance and the decay of personal independence. Rav Salanter understood the direct connection between clinging to communal consensus and the decline of individual courage.
In the pursuit of attaining that elevated sense of personal autonomy, he engaged in structuring extraordinary activities for his followers. He would advise them to act publicly in ways that would invite disdain, rebuke, or bewilderment. He would suggest that an individual not speak to anyone for a day. He would recommend for an individual to stand in a public space and attempt to balance an egg on his head. His goal was not to make people look ridiculous. His objective was to train them to be independent. He believed that in a world where consensus, social approval, and societal acceptance were dominating human conduct, independent courage was a mandatory component of Jewish character.
Only when a person can withstand humiliation, scorn, and condescension can he develop the internal fortitude to be courageous in defense of precious principles that are foundational to a pious character. Only when a person can summon his religious and moral autonomy can he find the courage to speak or take action that may be antithetical to public opinion.
We need voices in the religious community — voices that are independent and courageous — that seek alternative views in confronting a challenging world. It is disheartening that rabbis ordained at Chovevei Torah are rejected from speaking in many synagogues. It is distressing that some of those rabbis who would reject granting the pulpit to a rabbi from Chovevei might consider yielding their pulpit to Israeli cabinet ministers Ben-Gvir or Smotrich. It is unacceptable that many rabbis cannot summon the historic consciousness to speak out against the inhumanity and uncivilized conduct that populates our headlines.
More rabbis should summon the halachic independence of Rabbi Kalischer, the spiritual innovativeness of the Baal Shem Tov, and the moral heroism of Rabbi Morais. Our faith community needs models of halachic courage and independence. In an age that beckons us to assert our humanity and repudiate incivility, we are in desperate need of religious leaders who are heroic.
Jack Nelson is a longtime resident of Bergen County. For many years he practiced law in New York; now he is a business executive.