‘We were helping the preschool — and the preschool was helping us’

‘We were helping the preschool — and the preschool was helping us’

How HCELC found a home at Beth Haverim Shir Shalom in Mahwah

How did Holy Cross Early Learning Center, a faith-based nonprofit preschool for 2- to 5-year-olds in Mahwah, find a home at Beth Haverim Shir Shalom, a Reform synagogue in town?

Iris Greenberg has been the synagogue’s executive director since 2004. “It was bashert,” she said about the relationship with HCELC.

Beth Haverim — House of Friends — was founded in 1970, and the Reform Temple of Suffern — Shir Shalom followed in 1971. The two merged in 2007 to become Beth Haverim Shir Shalom. The new synagogue had a religious school but did not have a preschool.

“Like many temples that consider opportunities for growth, the Beth Haverim Shir Shalom executive committee had been exploring ways to generate activities with the space in our building and the land around it,” Ms. Greenberg said. “We evaluated various possibilities, but nothing felt like the right fit. 

“It was an unexpected knock on our door that brought an eager and willing lessee to us two years ago.” That knock came from Carrie Bryant-Render, the director of Holy Cross Early Learning Center — a preschool right across the street. 

Ms. Bryant-Render grew up in a Lutheran home in Frederick, Maryland. “My family members were active members of the local Evangelical Lutheran Church,” she said. “Our connection to the Holy Cross Lutheran Church and Nursery School in Mahwah began in 2009 when my husband, Jeremy, and our three children joined the church as parishioners and our oldest daughter, Logan, began preschool.”

Ms. Bryant-Render’s children, Logan, Luke, and Kolton, attended preschool at Holy Cross from 2009 through 2016 before the youngest started public school in Mahwah. “We moved from Mahwah to Oakland in 2013, and the same year, I was asked to serve as a consultant and financial liaison between the school and the church,” she said. In 2014, when the preschool director, Lesley Ayre, retired, Ms. Bryant-Render took that position.

An HCELC kid plays in the shul’s playground.

Due to aging congregants, a lack of new members, and the inability to sustain itself financially, Holy Cross Church closed in 2017, but the preschool was allowed to operate for the next year under the supervision of the state regional Lutheran district. “In 2018, we created our own 501(c) 3 nonprofit in education for preschool,” Ms. Bryant-Render said. She, head teacher Veronica Kellner, and office manager Laura Valvo were appointed as trustees. The school changed its name to Holy Cross Early Learning Center at the start of the 2018-2019 school year.

The preschool rented its space in the church building for another five years, serving families from Mahwah, Suffern, Oakland, and Ramsey. But in 2022 the trustees learned that it would have to find a new home. “We looked for space at other local churches with no success,” Ms. Bryant-Render said. “We also reached out to commercial real estate properties — corporate centers in Mahwah that had a minimum of 5,500 feet — but not only was there a lack of playgrounds available for the children, there also were concerns about the noise that might result from 85 kids taking part in an active school day. Potential landlords saw a lot of red tape with licensing through the state as well. 

“We were close to securing space at Ramapo College, but that fell through for another project they’d been planning.” 

In 2022, BHSS had just completed the installation of a brand-new playground, courtesy of an anonymous donor.

“As our preschool students watched the day-to-day construction of a brand-new, colorful playground across the street, they asked if it was going to be their new playground,” Ms. Bryant-Render said. “This tugged at our heartstrings, knowing the frustration we were all feeling about losing our sacred space. For decades, so many families from our surrounding communities had been dedicated to our preschool.”

Also, she added, “closing our doors meant that 20 competent teachers and support staff would be out of a job.” 

It was her daughter Logan who encouraged Ms. Bryant-Render to ask about space at Beth Haverim Shir Shalom. 

Iris Greenberg

Ms. Bryant-Render had known Ms. Greenberg, because sometimes BHSS needed overflow parking space for large events and Ms. Greenberg would call the HCELC office to ask about available church space. “When I began speaking with Iris about our plight, she was incredibly understanding,” Ms. Bryant-Render said.

“I was eager to take Carrie on a tour of the temple, starting with the playground, then the social hall, then all the classroom space we could make available to her since the religious school students didn’t use it until after-school hours,” Ms. Greenberg said.

“In 2016, the old storage house on the property was demolished and a new building was erected on the same footprint. The new space, called the Ulam or gathering hall, has 1,200 square feet of space that we outsource for yoga, SAT courses, board meetings, extended kiddush luncheons, and other functions.”

Ms. Greenberg promised to take the idea of renting space to HCELC to her executive committee and the board. “I saw the business opportunity as a good one for both parties involved,” she said. “At the time our temple president was Linda Schwartz, our treasurer was Harvey Weinberg, and our assistant treasurer was Andy Silver. We started meeting and talking and decided to have another meeting with Carrie and her team of trustees. 

“It wasn’t just about logistics. There were other things to consider. But we’d certainly not disregard the request just because the preschool needing a home was a ‘light’ faith-based program housed in a church.” 

Ms. Bryant-Render explained how she leads a school whose initials stand for Holy Cross Early Learning Center, now that it’s housed in a synagogue.

“We grew as a Christian preschool, but now that we’re at BHSS, out of courtesy, we refer to ourselves as faith-based because the students are learning about many different faiths and we honor many different beliefs,” she said.

HCELC executive director Carrie Bryant-Render, left, and Linda Ellman Schwartz, who was the synagogue’s president, sign the agreement.

“With the blessing of our rabbi, Ilana Schwartzman, our director of education, Rebecca McVeigh, our past president, Linda Ellman Schwartz, and our current president, Lauren Theodore, joined me, our treasurer, our assistant treasurer, and our executive committee, and then thereafter our board of trustees to discuss all the details. We wanted our members to recognize that this was a beneficial financial decision for us. We were signing a multiyear lease, not renting the space for one event.

“We wanted to be transparent. Within the span of a year, we planned several town hall meetings with the congregation to outline our plans to lease space to the preschool. We gave our members a chance to ask questions. It was shortly thereafter that the executive committee and board agreed to bring the preschool to Beth Haverim Shir Shalom.” 

The school hired attorneys who helped it negotiate the lease. The synagogue hired attorneys to help it navigate the requests from the town. Eventually, Ms. Bryant-Render and Ms. Greenberg went before the town board to submit their request for the move across the street.

“The town council signed off on the move after voting a unanimous yes,” Ms. Greenberg said. “They were pleased that the preschool, which had served 70 to 100 children annually since 1958, would be remaining in Mahwah. 

“We were helping the preschool — and the preschool was helping us.”

In May 2024, HCELC called an all-school meeting to tell the families what was happening. “While there were initially many questions and many walk-throughs to see the facility, the level of support for the move by our families was overwhelmingly positive,” Ms. Bryant-Render said. “We left a four-room schoolhouse with an old, rundown playground for an amazing preschool campus.”

There were many formalities, state rules, and regulations that the preschool had to uphold to make the move to BHSS. That took months. But both Ms. Bryant-Render and Ms. Greenberg saw the experience as truly uplifting. “Our personalities meshed, and we wanted our connection to succeed,” Ms. Greenberg said.”

Rabbi Ilana Schwartzman talks to HCELC preschools in the synagogue’s sukkah as HCELC teachers Ms. Sarah and Ms. Nicole look on.

Ms. Greenberg noted that the synagogue leadership held many meetings with the synagogue’s members to explain what they were planning to do and how they were planning to do it. Some questions came up about the name: Holy Cross. “We explained that the signage for the preschool would change from Holy Cross Early Learning Center to HCELC,” Ms. Greenberg said. “We also assured our membership that there would be no religious symbols in the classroom, such as a cross, visible.”

“HCELC cultivates an environment where children are taught about different beliefs rather than teaching them what to believe,” Ms. Bryant-Render said. “We’re teaching the children about good decisions and ethics. Our preschool’s old logo had handprints in the sign of the cross, but out of courtesy to our landlords, we manipulated the logo by spreading the handprints out so there isn’t as much of a connection to Jesus.”

“Two faiths operating under one roof means students and staff are learning from each other,” Ms. Greenberg said. “Our shared spaces include an Israeli flag and a mezuzah on each classroom door.”

Because the space is shared, Beth Haverim Shir Shalom’s caretaker, Roberto Lara, works hard to “turn over the classrooms on Mondays and Tuesdays by 3 in the afternoon from the preschool, which is still in session, to the religious school set-up,” Ms. Greenberg said. “Religious school students require a different set-up and our full-sized desks and chairs need to be in place.” As this happens, the preschoolers gather in Ulam. 

Since the first day of classes in September 2025, the preschool and synagogue communities have become a family. And in the spirit of connection and community, Rabbi Schwartzman and BHSS’s director of education, Rebecca McVeigh, have made every effort to engage the preschool students in Jewish rituals. Rabbi Schwartzman, who sees the preschool as “faith-based light,” enjoys teaching students about the Jewish holidays. In the early days of the transition, when the children were getting used to the new location, she understood their apprehension. “I still see her kneeling down to a child’s level when someone is crying,” Ms. Greenberg said.

Ms. Bryant-Render agrees with the open-mindedness and inclusion to which the HCELC and synagogue staff subscribe. “The Christmas show, a 60-year tradition of the preschool to focus the program on the birth of Jesus, is now called the Holiday Show,” she said. “We include songs about Christmas, Chanukah, winter, and snowflakes.” 

“We invite the preschool community to our annual Family Fun Day, and we’re invited to the preschool families’ annual International Night,” Ms. Greenberg said. In March 2026, Ms. Greenberg was honored with a framed image expressing the HCELC’s gratitude for such a welcoming shared space. 

“Since 1958, the preschool’s teaching principles have been more about God than religion,” Ms. Bryant-Render said. “We want the students to understand that God is present in our lives just like the air we breathe. And in leading us to Beth Haverim Shir Shalom. God knew what we needed before we knew what we needed.” 

For more information, go to bethhaverim.org

read more: