Rabbi Katz of Ner Tamid: ‘We’ve unfortunately been preparing for this’
Temple Ner Tamid in Bloomfield is crediting recent safety improvements after a Molotov cocktail thrown at its door early last Sunday morning caused little damage.
Still, Ner Tamid canceled activities that day as the police investigated. It was the second time in recent months that the suburban congregation suspended activities because of an antisemitic incident.
Last November, the Reform synagogue of about 500 families briefly closed its doors while the FBI investigated a “credible threat” against New Jersey synagogues; an 18-year-old man was arrested for making a threat online.
The latest incident took place around 3 a.m. on Sunday, when, according to security camera footage, a man approached the synagogue and threw what appeared to be a Molotov cocktail — a homemade bomb — at the door before fleeing. The man was wearing a ski mask and a shirt that appeared to have an image of a skull and crossbones, according to a picture that police distributed.
The building suffered only superficial damage, an outcome that Rabbi Marc Katz attributed to the safety investments made over the past several years, funded largely by state homeland security grants. The synagogue has added shatterproof glass to its door and upgraded its security cameras, which generated a relatively clear image of the man who threw the device.
“Everything worked the way it was supposed to,” Rabbi Katz said on Sunday afternoon. “We’ve unfortunately been preparing for this day for a while and we were ready.”
The synagogue canceled religious school, where roughly 200 children had been expected, and a rehearsal for the year’s Purim play, largely out of concern that it would be upsetting for community members to see evidence of the assault and the investigation, Rabbi Katz said. On Monday, a scheduled book talk by Rabbi Joshua Stanton, whose recent book tackles the challenges facing American religious institutions, has been postponed to make way for an evening event focused on the incident.
But Rabbi Katz emphasized, including in his communications to community members, that the community’s normal activities also were ongoing. On Sunday morning, he said, he had officiated at a baby naming, and other activities would proceed as planned on Monday.
Katz said there had been no warning before the Molotov cocktail. But he noted that neighboring Montclair has experienced many apparently antisemitic incidents in recent years, including swastikas found on playgrounds and etched on desks in the high school.
“Every few months, something happens,” he said. “But this is the first time that there’s something directly against our congregation to this magnitude. If things had been different, like even the wind blowing differently, we could be having a very different conversation. “That’s what’s so scary about this.”
Rabbi Katz said that even as the incident had left him and his congregants shaken, it was not just antisemitic incidents such as the attacks on synagogues in Pittsburgh; Poway, California; and Colleyville, Texas that had created an atmosphere of fear in the community. He said that every year he asks teenagers in the congregation where they feel more unsafe, at synagogue or at school, and every year the answers come back split.
“Our kids are suffering, and they’re not just suffering because they’re Jewish,” he said. “So we have to be responding with a bit of a wider lens even than just what our own community is facing.”
In his letter to congregants, Rabbi Katz noted that Ner Tamid’s trauma stood alongside other crises in the United States, alluding to many shootings targeting Asians in California and the release of footage showing police officers beating a Black man to death in Memphis.
“This has been a horrible week for many, for the AAPI community, for the African American community, and yes, for us,” Rabbi Katz wrote. “If you don’t know what to do in light of this, then offer up support to a community who is equally at a loss. Perhaps in our collective anger and grief, we can find a way out together.”
Jewish Telegraphic Agency