American Jews are likely to vote for Hillary Clinton in November, but American Jewry’s fastest-growing community is likely to go the other way.
A solid majority of charedi Orthodox Jews will vote for Donald Trump, say experts and Republican operatives in the charedi enclave of Borough Park, Brooklyn. While poll data isn’t available on the fervently Orthodox vote, observers say the charedim are attracted by Trump’s hawkish foreign policy, pugnacious personality, and image as a successful businessman.
It doesn’t hurt that he’s a man.
“When you’re fighting a war, you want someone who’s tough, who’s going to be on your side,” said Heshy Friedman, a business consultant in Borough Park who founded the group Jewish Democrats for Trump. “I don’t think he means things literally. You need somebody who borderlines on going crazy.”
The charedi community in New York City and in New York state has supported Democrats in the past. Both Mayor Bill de Blasio and Gov. Andrew Cuomo have courted the charedi vote by ensuring social services for the poor and promising not to intrude in communal affairs. Borough Park’s state assemblyman, Dov Hikind, is a conservative Democrat.
But unlike American Jews in general, who overwhelmingly have voted for Democrats in national elections for a century, the charedi community has shifted Republican in the past couple of decades as its numbers have grown, according to Samuel Heilman, who has studied the community for decades as a sociologist at Queens College of the City University of New York. The charedi move rightward parallels a similar move among all American Orthodox Jews, who include the less insular modern Orthodox community.
A recent poll of Florida Jews found that Orthodox voters there back Trump by a 3-to-1 margin.
“The charedi community clearly leans toward the Republican Party,” said Hikind, who is undecided in the presidential election. “Mostly it’s been Republican because of the sense that Republicans are much closer to Israel, much friendlier to Israel.”
Charedim vote Republican, Heilman said, both to distinguish themselves from less observant Jews and because they identify with the party’s social conservatism. He said this election could push charedim to Trump in especially large numbers because Clinton is a woman. Voting a woman into the most powerful position in the world, Heilman said, would be hard for a community whose gender roles are so clearly defined that its newspapers don’t even print photographs of women, including public figures like Clinton.
“They don’t want to be like the rest of the Jews,” Heilman said. “The idea that a woman can have the ultimate position doesn’t sit right with them. When the president of the United States makes news, they can’t put a picture of her in Yated Neeman,” a leading charedi paper.
Yated Neeman’s editor, Pinchos Lipschutz, has written several columns praising Trump for being authentic while bashing Clinton’s perceived dishonesty. In a February column, he wrote that the voters are supporting Trump almost like the Children of Israel supported Moses.
“He gives voice to the attitude that empowers the people,” Lipschutz wrote in that column. “He talks about the real fear in American homes, the desire to triumph, the hope of being winners again. He continues to fill large arenas, peddling that message, and by doing so, he makes the professional politicians look silly.”
Friedman, who also campaigned for Republican presidents Ronald Reagan and George W. Bush, has been making the policy case for Trump in Borough Park. A flier he posted in synagogues around the neighborhood lists four reasons to support Trump: opposition to Iran obtaining a nuclear bomb, support for Israeli West Bank settlement, his pledge to nominate a conservative Supreme Court justice, and his opposition to Syrian refugees entering the country.
Friedman changed his license plate to “TRUMP 17” in honor of the candidate’s would-be inauguration year, and believes there is a “silent majority” of charedi Jews who are too bashful to voice their support for Trump. He says support for Trump is especially strong among young charedim, who use the internet and have access to right-wing websites.
“You have a whole new generation of yeshiva kids who are right wing,” he said. “[Democrats] are trying to destroy the religious community. These people have an agenda, and when they start the fight, there’s always a reaction.”
Trump’s controversial statements and brusque demeanor have left some Borough Park Jews ambivalent. Like Orthodox Jews in Florida, several said that they were dissatisfied with both candidates and still are weighing their options.
Hikind, a Democrat who has supported Republicans in the past, made a video two weeks ago coming out against Clinton because of her support for the agreement last year curbing Iran’s nuclear program, an agreement that critics deem weak. He stressed that he cannot yet endorse Trump because of the candidate’s divisive statements, though Hikind expected most of his charedi constituents to back the developer and TV reality star.
“There’s nothing to cheer about with regard to Trump because of so many things he’s said, so many things he’s done,” Hikind said. “Donald Trump is the kind of guy, I don’t know what he’s going to say tomorrow, I don’t know what he’s going to say next week, I don’t know what he’s going to say two weeks from now that may disqualify him.”
The largest charedi communities in the United States are in New York and New Jersey, traditionally Democratic states that almost certainly will go to Clinton even if the charedim turn out massively for Trump. But Friedman says highlighting the charedi vote is important both because more liberal Jews look to charedim to validate their Jewish choices, and because a high charedi birth rate means that it is the future of the Jewish community.
“If you go to a restaurant and you see somebody with a black hat and a long beard sitting there eating with his family, you know it’s definitely kosher,” he said. “The secular Jewish people, there’s many who look up to the Orthodox community and say if they’re voting so strongly for this particular candidate, then obviously he must be somebody who’s good for the Jewish community.”
JTA Wire Service