For close to 30 years, leaders of Polish Jewry have been celebrating what they call the revival of their once-great community from near annihilation during the Holocaust.
On occasions like the opening of Jewish kindergartens and other communal institutions, often held up as the first since the genocide, activists note milestones, contrasting them with the preceding devastation, communist-era oppression, or worrying developments elsewhere in Europe.
“As Europe is becoming more difficult to be Jewish in, Poland is going in the other direction,” one key promoter of Jewish life in Poland, Jonathan Ornstein of the Krakow Jewish Community Center, said recently. He invited readers to “see this amazing rebirth of Jewish life.”
Poland, Ornstein noted, has small but growing Jewish communities in 15 cities and dozens of Jewish cultural festivals annually.
Others waxed lyrical about local expressions of philo-Semitism, like an odd but well-meaning mock Jewish wedding that took place last month in Radzanow. Few of the guests there actually were Jewish.
“It’s amazing that this heritage created by 3.5 million murdered Jews is still relevant today,” Jonny Daniels, founder of From the Depths, a group for Holocaust commemoration in Poland, said of the wedding.
But in recent weeks, this narrative has given way to warnings by communal leaders of resurgent and potentially violent anti-Semitism that they say is being tolerated, if not encouraged, by the nationalist government that came to power in 2015. In turn, other Polish Jews have dismissed these warnings as exaggerated and a partisan attempt to hurt the government.
The split within the community, observers say, leaves it open to government divide-and-rule tactics.
Those insisting that the ruling Law and Justice party is not doing enough to address a rise in anti-Semitism include the head of the Warsaw community, Anna Chipczynska; the president of the Union of Jewish Communities in Poland, Leslaw Piszewski; and the European Jewish Congress.
“For years we’ve been talking about the miracle of the revival of Jewish life in Poland, of which we are all very proud,” Chipczynska said. “Jewish life in Poland is now a fact. But another fact is that there’s a security problem going on.”
The problem, she added, is growing threats in far-right circles acting with impunity from the government, requiring communities to spend more on security and generating concern. She noted racist rhetoric online and anti-Semitic remarks by lawmakers and even Cabinet ministers, as well as expressions of revisionism by state historians.
Recent incidents include a statement by lawmaker Bogdan Rzonca of Law and Justice, an anti-immigration party, who wrote on Twitter, “I wonder why there are so many Jews among those performing abortions, despite the Holocaust.” Two assaults by soccer hooligans on Israeli fans in Poland also were deemed anti-Semitic.
In July, Chipczynska and Piszewski wrote an open letter to a Law and Justice founder, Jarosław Kaczyński, protesting the perceived reality and asking for his intervention. It was the first such address by communal leaders, and it mentioned 1968, the year when state-sponsored anti-Semitism in communist Poland reached peak levels. Last week, the European Jewish Congress escalated the rhetoric even further, expressing “grave concern over the dramatic rise in anti-Semitism in Poland.”
In a statement that featured some of his group’s most sharply worded remarks in years about an EU member state, the European Jewish Congress president, Moshe Kantor, added that the government has “closed it communications with representatives of the official Jewish community” and “stands out as an example of leadership that seems to have little interest” in dialogue.
But some Polish Jews, including elected communal representatives, disagree with those expressing “grave” concerns over anti-Semitism. Artur Hofman, the president of TSKZ, a Polish Jewish cultural organization, whose 1,200 members in 15 cities make it the largest Polish-Jewish organization in terms of membership, rejected both the claims of rising anti-Semitism in Poland and of government complacency toward it. The letter from Chipczynska and Piszewski is part of a “political war” by some left-wing Polish Jews against the ruling party, he said.
Bitter disputes among Jewish organizations are not uncommon in former communist countries, where personal and ideological rivalries often are exacerbated by the competition for government subsidies and restitution funds. The rise of nationalism in Hungary, Russia, Lithuania, and Ukraine has fueled similar feuds, where politics complicate the fight against anti-Semitism.
But Poland’s Jewish community had managed to avoid such splintering — at least publicly — until earlier this year, according to Piotr Kadlcik, the previous president of the federation of Polish Jewish communities. “It’s sad to watch,” Kadlcik said.
The split was on display on August 17, when Hofman, Daniels, and two Chabad rabbis met with Kaczyński, the ruling party official. Kaczyński so far has snubbed requests for meetings from other community leaders. But he posed for a photo with Hofman’s group two weeks after receiving the accusatory letter co-written by Chipczynska. After the meeting, which Hofman said was pleasant and earnest, Hofman defended the government and dismissed the allegations Chipczynska raised.
“What anti-Semitism?” he asked? “What on earth are they talking about? In this country, I can walk around with a kippah anywhere I like, unlike in Berlin, Paris, Brussels. I go to Jewish cultural festivals in the middle of the street with no security. In France you would need an army battalion to give security.”
Chipczynska rejected any partisan motives in writing the letter and cited figures suggesting that hate speech and hate crime are on the rise in Poland. While the claim is supported in some reports, it is challenged in others, and by the government. Physical attacks on Jews in Poland are extremely rare. The total number of anti-Semitic incidents recorded there annually is no greater than a few dozen. That is a fraction of the tallies for several countries in Western Europe.
The meeting with Kaczyński, in which he said anti-Semitism is and will stay a fringe phenomenon, did little to settle the debate on the alleged rise in anti-Semitism in Poland. But it opened a new feud among Jews on who gets to meet with senior politicians.
After the meeting, representatives of 14 Jewish groups — including Michael Schudrich, the chief rabbi of Poland — signed a statement declaring that Hofman and the others present at the encounter represented no one but themselves. One communal leader, Sergiusz Kowalski, president of the Polish branch of B’nai B’rith, called the Jewish participants at the meeting “court Jews.”
The European Jewish Congress last week said the same thing, albeit in more civil terms. “The transparent divide-and-rule tactic of senior leaders of the Law and Justice Party in seeking to choose its selected Jewish interlocutors over the heads of official and representative community organizations in Poland leaves us staggered and reminds us of much darker times in Europe when governments chose their Jews,” its press release said.
JTA Wire Service